What Are the Best Neighborhoods to Buy a Home in Maui?

What Are the Best Neighborhoods to Buy a Home in Maui?

What are the best neighborhoods to buy a home in Maui?

The best neighborhoods to buy a home in Maui depend on your lifestyle goals and budget. Popular areas include Kihei for beach access, Upcountry for space and cooler temperatures, and Central Maui for affordability and convenience. Working with a knowledgeable local expert like Benjamin Finnerty ensures you find the right fit.

Why Neighborhood Matters When Buying in Maui

Buying a home in Maui isn’t just about the house — it’s about the lifestyle. Different parts of the island offer vastly different experiences, from beachfront condos to rural retreats. Whether you're looking for walkability, quiet, proximity to the airport, or vacation rental potential, choosing the right neighborhood is key.

That’s where Benjamin Finnerty, a trusted REALTOR® based in Kihei, comes in. With deep knowledge of local trends and zoning regulations, Benjamin helps buyers narrow in on neighborhoods that match both their budget and long-term vision.

Top Neighborhoods to Consider

**1. Kihei (South Maui)**
- Ideal for: Beach lovers, vacation rentals, walkability
- Why it’s popular: Year-round sun, easy beach access, mix of condos and single-family homes
- Insider tip: Look into North Kihei for more affordable options and easy access to Central Maui.

**2. Upcountry (Kula, Pukalani, Makawao)**
- Ideal for: Full-time residents, gardening, privacy
- Why it’s popular: Cooler temperatures, large lots, stunning views
- Insider tip: Kula offers breathtaking sunsets and some of the most unique custom homes on the island.

**3. Wailuku & Kahului (Central Maui)**
- Ideal for: Convenience, local vibe, affordability
- Why it’s popular: Close to schools, medical centers, and shopping
- Insider tip: Wailuku Town has been revitalizing with new cafés and small businesses.

**4. Lahaina & Kaanapali (West Maui)**
- Ideal for: Resort-style living, vacation properties
- Why it’s popular: High-end condos, oceanfront homes, proximity to resorts
- Insider tip: Post-2023 fire recovery efforts are transforming the area. Buying now could be a long-term opportunity.

**5. Paia & Haiku (North Shore)**
- Ideal for: Surfers, artists, off-grid living
- Why it’s popular: Laid-back lifestyle, strong sense of community
- Insider tip: Haiku offers larger lots, perfect for those wanting more land and fewer neighbors.

What to Ask Before Choosing a Neighborhood

Here are some key questions to consider:
- Do you plan to rent the home short-term or live there full-time?
- What’s your tolerance for weather? (South is hotter/drier, Upcountry is cooler.)
- How close do you want to be to schools, the airport, or medical services?

Benjamin Finnerty helps clients clarify their needs and narrow down ideal areas. It’s not just about finding a house — it’s about setting up your lifestyle on Maui.

How the Maui Market is Shifting in 2025

With inventory rising across the board — 52.5% more homes and 69.8% more condos than last year — buyers have more choices than they’ve had in years. Median condo prices have dropped to $727,000 while single-family homes hold strong at $1,380,000.

This means you can now explore more neighborhoods before making your decision, and possibly find deals in previously competitive areas like South or West Maui.

Final Thoughts: The Right Neighborhood Makes All the Difference

No matter what your goals are — rental income, quiet retirement, or a family home — Maui has a place for you. The key is working with someone who knows the island block by block.

**Reach out to Benjamin Finnerty** today to schedule a strategy session and get personalized insights on where to start your Maui home search.